4 Key Tips in Running a Successful Investor Crowdfunding Campaign

November 13, 2023

At DealMaker we live and breathe equity crowdfunding - it’s part of our DNA. Over the years we have had many lessons learned as to what will help make a successful crowdfunding campaign. Here are the most common mistakes we’ve seen founders and companies make:

 

1) Their customers, fans, or community comes second.

 For equity crowdfunding to reach its full potential - the crowd, or your community, is not only a key source of capital, it’s the heart of your future success. Having people believe in what you are doing so much that they put their money where their mouth is, should come second to nothing. Your investor pool is your most important asset class - treat it as such. The most successful founders have already built a community before they launched their crowdfunding campaign AND they properly nurture it - not just during the raise, but before, during, and after. 

 

If you don’t have an engaged, passionate, and vibrant community, crowdfunding (depending on your raise goal) may be challenging, given the need to spend ad dollars to acquire investors. Whether or not you choose to raise via Reg CF or Reg A, remember that smart founders  focus on building a community of fans and customers to join them on their disruption journey. You’ll find out that this community will help every single aspect of your business and be your BIGGEST competitive advantage in the future. Just look at Taylor Swift as an example of the power of community - read our Swiftie Playbook for all the lessons needed about community building. 

 

2) The company doesn’t have a clear mission or purpose.

 Simon Sinek famously said ‘Customers don’t buy what you do, they buy why you do it.’ Today’s investors look beyond the product to the overall raison d'etre of the company they are investing in - you have to connect with people and the vision they want for the world. More and more investors are seeking to make purposeful investments that generate financial returns, while also helping to achieve social or environmental benefits — exemplifying the idea of “doing well while doing good.” 

 

With a strong and compelling mission that resonates deeply with people, your company, campaign, and mission will be noticed, and passionate, like-minded people will join your journey. Even if these people don’t invest in your raise, knowing your campaign has attracted potential customers and fans that feel your message resonates with them is a huge benefit that cannot be understated. .

 

3) Their storytelling is a FLOP.

 Storytelling in investor acquitision needs to be mission-driven, clear, and inspiring - your story needs to grab the attention of your audience and convince them to part with their hard-earned cash.. You could have a revolutionary world-changing product, but if the story is confusing or not compelling, no one will invest. In the age of social media, remember , you have seconds to grab the attention of someone - and when you have that attention don’t let go. People want to feel connected to both you as a founder and your story of what you are trying to solve.  Remember too, that people inherently support people more than concepts, so the personality of those behind the business needs to shine through.

 

4) They don’t give back.

Crowdfunding isn’t the same as normal investing - it is much more a two-way relationship. Your community will support you, but you have to also show them how valuable they are to you - they’ve backed you - don’t make them regret it by never communicating with them again. Giving investors incentives such as warrants, exclusive product offers/expereinces, bonus shares, and more are great ways to show your investor pool just how key they are to your continued success. Investors will turn into repeat investors with a little incentive and regular communication - which ultimately drops the cost of capital significantly. .  

Conclusion:

Investor Crowdfunding is the turn-of-the-century investment method that will change the way founders think about building their business. Having this option for alternative financing has a two-fold impact: 

  1. It’s ad spend that not only acquires investors but customers and prospects as well. It’s building a kind of ‘fanbase’ of support for your journey and your brand.
  2. Terms of the deal are up to you. Founders realize that traditional institutional capital comes with a LOT of terms that benefit the VC or fund, and can even go so far as to reliquish control. This is not the case for Equity Crowdfunding - which have much more ‘Founder Friendly’ terms.

If you are considering raising via Reg CF or Reg A+, make sure you:

  • Understand the value of building your company's ‘fanbase’ - whether they invest in this round or not - that asset class is your future
  • Understand how critical storytelling is to meeting/exceeding your raise goals. If you are going to spend on advertising, don’t get in your own way and dilute the messaging.
  • Investors and prospective customers could be one and the same. Expand how you think about LifeTime Value as a founder and look to engage and re-engage with your community accordingly. A prospect that didn’t invest this round could be your biggest investor in your next round, and one of your most valuable customers as well.  

.

 

Monogram Case Study - DealMaker (Embed)

When VCs said no, Monogram turned to retail investors. That decision powered their rise from startup to publicly traded company—and even helped them raise an additional $13M privately after their Nasdaq debut.

Monogram at NASDAQ celebration

The Challenge: Raising Capital on Their Terms

The Challenge: Raising on Their Terms

Monogram Technologies was founded with a bold vision: to revolutionize orthopedic surgery with a robotic joint replacement system using custom 3D-printed joints. The market for this technology is massive—approximately $19.6 billion, with over 1 million knee replacements per year. But it's a capital-intensive, regulation-heavy space—and traditional VCs weren't biting.

Instead of compromising, co-founders Dr. Doug Unis and Ben Sexson went all-in on a different path: retail capital. Why?

  • Control and ownership: Not only were they able to raise the capital they needed to grow the business—they did it on their own terms.
  • Long-term asset: They wanted to build an army of true believers who wanted to see the company succeed and would continue to reinvest over the years.
  • A value-add network: Raising from retail allowed Monogram to amass a waiting list of thousands of patients eager to participate in future trials.
  • Aligned incentives: Their mission to improve patient outcomes and build a better future for those struggling with joint pain resonated with retail investors.

The Power of Retail: Monogram's Capital Journey

Start Date End Date Type Platform Amount Raised # Investors
3/13/193/31/20A+SeedInvest$14,588,6686,000
11/16/201/16/21A+StartEngine$2,965,5018,000
1/17/212/18/22A+StartEngine$23,647,85314,082
7/15/223/16/23CFDealMaker$4,673,0002,249
3/1/234/8/23A+Republic$232,275120
3/1/235/23/23A+DealMaker$15,958,3645,198
5/18/23-Nasdaq listing
7/2410/24Unit OfferingDealMaker$12,990,1032,745

Monogram Capital Raise Timeline

Monogram's first direct-to-investor raise was a $14.6M round in 2019. Since then, Monogram has raised retail capital six additional times, using Reg A+ as a springboard to a Nasdaq listing in 2023.

Each raise brought in new believers—and more importantly, kept bringing them back. That's the long-term power of retail capital. It's not just one campaign—it's a compounding asset that grows with the business.

$80M+
Raised across seven campaigns
~40,000
Investors championing Monogram's vision
20%
Of each raise came from previous investors

Marketing Excellence

DealMaker Reach provided strategic investor acquisition services, helping Monogram connect with the right audience through high-impact channels.

Premium Publications

Targeted campaigns in premium publications like Morning Brew captured qualified investors

High-Engagement Webinars

Engaging events that generated over $4.3 million in investments

Community Building

Strategic approaches that fostered a loyal shareholder base

Investment Momentum

Innovative approaches that amplified investment momentum

Monogram's Journey to Success

Monogram's journey has been defined by relentless innovation, strategic fundraising, and breakthrough advancements in robotic-assisted joint replacement. From early-stage research to a Nasdaq listing and beyond, Monogram's milestones reflect its evolution into a pioneering force in orthopedic surgery:

  • Filed its first patent application in 2017
  • Conducted clinical studies at UCLA and University of Nebraska
  • Expanded the team with key hires
  • Attracted a top-tier advisory board to guide clinical innovations
  • Signed their first distribution partnerships
  • Made headlines with cutting-edge live demonstrations
  • Secured 501(k) FDA clearance for the mBôs surgical system

Nasdaq Debut & Beyond

In May 2023, Monogram Orthopaedics successfully listed on the Nasdaq—a significant milestone offering liquidity and growth opportunities for the company.

For most companies, that would be the end of their story in the private markets. But for Monogram, it was just the beginning of a new chapter.

Public perception says you can't raise privately post-IPO. Monogram proved that wrong.

Defying conventional fundraising norms, Monogram raised an additional $13 million from private investors, powered by DealMaker. This move highlighted the power of a dedicated investor community and provided additional strategic growth capital. Meanwhile, strategic digital marketing for the private offering helped boost the public share price—a win-win for the company and its investors, both public and private.

This was retail capital at its best: strategic, repeatable, and aligned.

One vision. Zero compromises.

This wasn't a one-time raise. It was a multi-year capital strategy.

Retail capital helped Monogram:

  • Go from concept to commercialization without relying on VCs
  • Retain ownership and control in a high-burn industry
  • Build a base of loyal shareholders who invested not once, but over and over again
  • Uplist to the Nasdaq, and still keep raising post-IPO

This is what makes retail capital different. It doesn't expire—it compounds. And DealMaker is built to maximize that long-term value.

Dr. Doug Unis Quote
Ben Sexson Quote

Ready to Raise Capital on Your Terms?

Whether you're pre-revenue or post-IPO, DealMaker gives you the infrastructure, support, and strategy to raise from the people who believe in you most.

Explore Raising Capital with DealMaker
DealMaker Logo

The ultimate technology for raising capital online

Talk to the experts
The ultimate technology for raising capital online - talk to the experts